do something with the search function (and I don't know what)
It took me a while to work out how to search for films I wanted to add to my watchlist (not my diary). The add to diary button is obviously the main thing, but it took me a mo to work out that the magnifying glass to the left turns it into normal search. When in the Watchlist page, the instructions are great (e.g. hover or sidebar), but I was all "But how do I find the film??) and if you click add to diary, there isn't a way to turn that into a "add to watchlist" instead. Ugh, this is a terrible explanation, sorry.
I think we’re going to add the same auto-complete box on the watchlist page that you get on normal film lists. It works really well.
Thanks for the feedback, by the way. I think you explained it perfectly.
I’m not sure what we’re going to do with the search box. It may change soon though, because the “Add to diary” button is getting an overhaul. Big things are happening :-)